The impact of compulsory voting in australia essay example. The burden of inconvenience on voters could well serve to reduce the high level of voluntary compliance with compulsory enrolment and voting which has largely been forthcoming in australia. Compulsory voting for national elections was introduced in australia in 1924, following a pronounced fall in turnout at the 1922 federal election. If they do not, then they must prove they were ill or incapable of making it to the polling place or face an extensive fine.
Electoral and policy consequences of voter turnout. For more than eight decades, australia adopted the compulsory voting cv system for all its citizens during election period. There are currently 32 countries with compulsory voting, of which 19 including australia pursue it through enforcement. Is compulsory voting a solution to americas low voter.
Australian electoral rolls national library of australia. This system has proven to be not only effective in bring voters to the polls, but also effective in improving australia s democracy. In 1902 australia became the second country in the world, after new zealand, to extend voting rights to women. Jul 25, 2019 with australia s compulsory voting system comes additional flexibility for the voter.
Nov 07, 2011 here in australia, where we love freedom as much as anyone else, we have a mandatory voting regime that is well managed, corruptionfree, easy to access, cheap to run and has an approval rating of. In australia, where not voting is punished, voter turnout is at 90%. Opinion voting should be mandatory the new york times. Voting is a personal choice made by individuals who strongly believe in the parties they vote for. This paper analyzes the adoption of compulsory voting laws in australia as a unique opportunity to assess the effects of nearuniversal turnout. Australia introduced compulsory voting in 1924 at the election held two years previously, only 59. Compulsory voting, party stability and electoral advantage. Dissertation arturo maldonado v2 vanderbilt university. Comparatively, australia, a former colony of britain, has enjoyed high and steady voter participation since 1924 because of the implementation of compulsory voting. Aug 27, 20 as australia heads to the polls, some are asking whether the countrys compulsory voting policy is still necessary and relevant, reports the bbcs katie beck in sydney. Examining the impact of compulsory voting on voter turnout. Under the compulsory enrolment and voluntary voting regime prior to compulsory voting, australia achieved high federal election turnouts. Compulsory voting for and against 1 the main arguments for and against compulsory voting in australia can be organised into six opposed pairs. Do you support compulsory voting in australia and why.
Around threequarters of australians have consistently supported compulsory voting. Time to rethink compulsory voting, says australianus. Voting in australia is like a party since 1924, australian citizens over the age of 18 have been required to vote in federal elections, byelections and referendums. On the reasonableness of compelling citizens to vote. The electoral system of australia enforces compulsory voting. The netherlands adopted compulsory voting in 1917, along with universal suffrage for men and pr. In fact, countries such as australia enforce their voting requirement by imposing fines on nonvoters. The turnout at australian elections has never fallen below 90% since the introduction of compulsory voting. In australia voting is a civic duty comparable to other duties citizens perform like paying taxes, compulsorily attending school and performing jury duty. Aug 03, 2018 for many years in several countries, voting is non compulsory. The case for compulsory voting in the united states voter turnout in the united states is much lower than in other democracies.
Analyzing state and national elections from 19492010, we show that compulsory voting laws with weakly enforced fines increase turnout by roughly 10 percentage points. Using these data, the following questions will be examined. Australia has the oldest, and probably the most efficient, system of compulsory voting of any of the advanced democracies and there is evidence of strong popular support for compulsory voting. Within two decades, all state parliaments in australia had adopted compulsory voting. With compulsory voting, it is claimed that parliaments reflect more accurately the will of the electorate. Somin 2012 argues that while australia may present an ideal alternative to current political apathy in the united states, other countries with compulsory voting legislation compulsory voting legislation, such as argentina, lebanon, egypt, and the. Compulsory voting dilutes the power of lobby groups and pork barreling. Opponents of compulsory voting question its ability to increase voter turnout. Compulsory voting does not deny australians their freedom of choice.
Via a critique of the methodology used, we query estimations of the effectiveness of. Governments must consider the total electorate in policy formulation and management. In addition to these arguments, research has shown that compulsory voting has some distinct political consequences, the most evident being increased participation in elections. Somin 2012 argues that while australia may present an ideal alternative to current political apathy in the united states, other countries with compulsory voting legislation compulsory voting. The concept of compulsory voting reflects a strain in democratic theory in which voting is considered not merely a right but a duty. In this paper we address claims made by those supporting the abolition of compulsory voting about the relationship between turnout levels and compulsory voting. In 1901 most male british subjects over 21 and resident in australia could vote. First, i present a brief history of compulsory voting laws in australia and explain why this policy change provides such a unique opportunity. That place has compulsory voting, and to me, that worked out just fine.
How australias compulsory voting saved it from trumpism. Does compulsory voting increase support for leftist policy. In support of such claims, they often underplay the effect that compulsory voting has on turnout levels, their suggestion being that the cost to personal freedom is not justified by the gains to democracy. Critics of australia s compulsory voting1 laws usually complain that such laws are an unjustifiable imposition on personal autonomy. Chapter 8 voluntary and compulsory voting parliament of. How america can benefit from australias compulsory voting. Pdf compulsory voting and the promotion of human rights in. When queensland introduced compulsory voting in 1915, it became the first place in the then british empire to do so. Strategy and ideas combined, unpublished paper presented to the ecpr joint sessions workshop on compulsory voting, helsinki, may 7 12, 2007. Dec 04, 2014 in australia, for example, which has had compulsory voting in federal elections since 1924, eligible citizens must mark a ballot they dont have to choose a candidate or pay a small fine. However, there are a number of nations that impose mandatory voting. Map of countries with compulsory or voluntary voting policies in 20158. Compulsory voting is an effect of laws which require eligible citizens to register and vote in. Most democratic governments consider participating in national.
In 1962, the commonwealth electoral act gave aboriginal people the right to enrol and vote at federal. With australia s compulsory voting system comes additional flexibility for the voter. Who supported compulsory voting both before and after. Should australia abolish compulsory voting and should the voting.
A second electoral matters committee report in 2005 recommended compulsory voting be the subject of a future inquiry. Queensland was the first state to introduce compulsory voting in 1915. For many years in several countries, voting is non compulsory. Therefore, it appears that the adoption of compulsory voting arose more for practical or principled reasons than it did for strategic reasons. First, compulsory voting, as it is practised in australia, promotes the right to vote itself simply by removing most of the ergonomic, practical and even psychological costs of voting that often. Argentina introduced the compulsory voting in 1912 for citizens aged 18 to 70 while it is nonmandatory for citizens who are over 70 years old and from 16 to 18 years. While the adoption of compulsory voting was not random, the timing. Dec 06, 2014 australias voting system is the one that is known the most. Predicted probabilities are calculated from multilevel linear regressions reported in models 1 and 2 of table 1. Elections are held on saturdays, absent voters can vote in any state polling place, and voters in remote areas can vote before an election at prepoll voting centers or via mail. In 1964, we ratified the 24th amendment, which prohibits making voting contingent on paying a. A provision in the constitution describing voting as a duty remained until 1999.
Australia has the oldest and probably the most efficient system of compulsory voting among the established democracies. These are the 27 countries where voting is compulsory map with almost 35% of registered south africans not voting this week, weve taken a look at countries where voting has been. For example, according to pew research, turnout plunged in chile after it moved from compulsory to voluntary voting in 2012. And that was the lowest turnout since the country introduced compulsory voting in 1924. The main reason for its introduction in the 1920s was to increase turnout, a goal it has achieved without difficulty. It works against political apathy because everybody has to form their own opinion. Why compulsory voting can enhance democracy article pdf available in acta politica 421. Voting in australia australian electoral commission. Every opinion poll taken since 1943 has found that three in every four australians support compulsory voting. Australia was born not on the battlefields but at the ballot box. But in australia in 2016, about 87 percent of voting age people participated in the nations federal election, or 91 percent of enrolled voters. Such system requires all citizens from age 18 and above to register to vote and go to a polling place to cast their vote during the election period. The electoral system of australia enforces compulsory voting, which means that a all citizens are required to vote.
We study a unique quasiexperiment in austria, where compulsory voting laws are changed across austrias nine states at different times. Electoral rolls list people who are registered to vote at federal, state, territory and local. What was the level of support for compulsory voting in 1966 and in 1999 and has support changed after the repeal of compulsory voting. But it fell from 75 percent to 65 percent in countries with voluntary. If someone is over the age of 18 in australia, then they must be registered to vote and show up at their polling place on election date. In a wellwritten essay that draws upon your reading, experience, or observations for support, take a position on the issue of compulsory voting.
Both of these factors would tend to diminish rather than enhance the legitimacy of australian election processes. Australian electoral rolls contain the following details on each registered voter. Australia has one of the oldest systems of compulsory voting. As of august 20, 22 countries provided for compulsory voting, 11 of whom enforced it during the first two decades of the 21st century, bulgaria has briefly introduced compulsory voting, while chile, cyprus, the dominican republic. Although 22 countries have compulsory voting, only 11 enforce it. First, compulsory voting, as it is practised in australia, promotes the right to vote itself simply by removing most of the ergonomic, practical and. Voting rights who can vote and have a say in australian democracy has changed substantially since federation.
Compulsory voting is wrong and should not be forced on anyone. Citizenship, duties and rights for against voting is a necessary part of the duties of citizenship, just like jury duty or paying taxes. Compulsory voting is unconstitutional the heritage. This system has proven to be not only effective in bring voters to the polls, but also effective in improving australias democracy. How compulsory voting can become a reality in the united. One of the initial reasons for introducing compulsory voting in australia, and one of the arguments frequently advanced for maintaining it, is that it maintains a high level of participation in elections. This topic is highly related to electoral participation due to the fact that compulsory voting increases participation, which is one of the most robust. Variation in the implementation of compulsory voting in latin america. Compulsory voting, party stability and electoral advantage in. Well, i lived in australia long enough to get its citizenship. There is no denying that the advantages are obvious. The main example of this new interest for the obligation to vote is. Australia illustrates how much compulsory voting can increase. People in this situation are asked to explain their failure to vote.
Political scientist emilee chapman says compulsory voting conveys the. As australia heads to the polls, some are asking whether the countrys compulsory voting policy is still necessary and relevant, reports the bbcs katie beck in sydney. Examining the impact of compulsory voting on voter. Compulsory voting is an effect of laws which require eligible citizens to register and vote in elections, and may impose penalties on those who fail to do so. The map below shows countries with no compulsory voting, compulsory voting and no elections. Nov 02, 2015 between 1945 and 2015, turnout hovered around 85 percent in compulsory voting countries like australia, belgium, and brazil. In some countries, notably australia and belgium, electoral participation is legally required, and nonvoters can face fines.
Compulsory voting for federal elections was introduced in 1924 and first used in the 1925 elections when 91. Some of the first countries that introduced mandatory voting laws were belgium in 1892, argentina in 1914 and australia. Many academic and popular writers have argued that compulsory voting is an illusion in australia because it is not compulsory to fill out the ballotpaper. Compulsory voting, turnout, and government spending. At present, the australian compulsory enrolment provisions are as wellenforced as in other english speaking countries, although there appears to be less compliance in australia. Compulsory voting, predicted programmatism, and predicted vote buying across countries. In all countries where compulsory voting is in place, turnout increased. Between 1945 and 2015, turnout hovered around 85 percent in compulsory voting countries like australia, belgium, and brazil. Enrolment and voting for aboriginal and torres strait islander peoples became compulsory in 1984. To prevent this state of affairs, some countries, such as australia, make voting compulsory for all adults. Queensland was the first australian state to introduce it in 1914, but voting did not become compulsory at. Critics of australias compulsory voting1 laws usually complain that such laws are an unjustifiable imposition on personal autonomy. Compulsory voting is unconstitutional the heritage foundation. In the years that followed, states across the country introduced compulsory voting starting with victoria in 1926, nsw and tasmania in 1928, western australia in 1936 and south australia in 1942.
The objective of this dissertation is to assess the operation of compulsory voting in latin america. The information may not be relevant to current electoral events. Compulsory voting has also made a major contribution to the longterm stability of the party system. These include argentina, australia, brazil, chile, ecuador, greece and singapore, to name a few.
256 1324 1515 535 924 754 58 249 1486 143 1286 873 1025 914 1569 946 227 957 1604 155 544 20 370 133 659 1055 439 1250 247 406 704 460 371 46 1122 949 1236 267 1325 440 431 297 164